URGENT UPDATE: In a dramatic showdown, Tottenville’s hopes for a PSAL 4A city championship were dashed as they fell to Erasmus Hall, 34-27, on October 29, 2023, at Midwood High School in Brooklyn, NY. The game began on a thrilling note as star running back Tyshawn Bent opened with a touchdown on the first kickoff, igniting the Pirates’ dreams of their first city title in 22 years.
However, Erasmus Hall quickly retaliated. The Dutchmen, led by a formidable trio—quarterback Kendu Brown, running back Ameir Morrow, and wide receiver Justus Murray—capitalized on their experience, turning the tide of the game decisively.
The match showcased the intensity and skill that both teams brought to the field. Despite a valiant effort, Tottenville’s season ended with a record of 12-1, marking a bittersweet conclusion. Head Coach Brian Neville expressed pride in his team’s performance throughout the season, even as they faced this heartbreaking loss.
Erasmus Hall, with this victory, not only avenged their earlier season loss to Tottenville but also clinched their seventh city championship. They now stand just one title behind Curtis for the all-time lead in PSAL history, with Curtis holding eight titles and Susan Wagner at six.
“We fought hard, but Erasmus showed their strength today,” said Coach Neville post-game. “I’m incredibly proud of our boys.”
As the dust settles on this thrilling championship battle, the impact on the community and the players is palpable. Fans rallied behind the Pirates, hoping for a fairy-tale finish, but Erasmus Hall’s victory solidifies their legacy as a powerhouse in high school football.
Looking ahead, Tottenville will regroup and aim to build on this season’s success, while Erasmus Hall celebrates and prepares for potential future challenges. The championship game has left an indelible mark on both teams, highlighting the fierce competition in New York City’s high school football landscape.
Stay tuned for more updates as we follow the aftermath of this thrilling championship game and its implications for both programs.
