Harris County commissioners are calling for increased transparency regarding plans to condemn part of Hermann Park for the expansion of Ben Taub Hospital. The proposal involves the use of eminent domain to acquire approximately 9 acres of parkland, specifically the area known as the Warneke track, which has been designated for public park use since its donation by the Warneke family to the City of Houston 114 years ago.
Commissioners expressed concern about the lack of public engagement in the process. According to reports, Harris Health executives have conducted discussions behind closed doors since 2024, aiming to push through the condemnation without sufficient community input. Real estate experts estimate that compensating the Warneke heirs could exceed $100 million. Several family members have publicly opposed the plan, further complicating the situation.
Dr. Esmaeli Porsa, President of Harris Health, defended the need for the land acquisition, stating that it is essential to address an urgent public health emergency. “The facts are this expansion is needed to address an urgent public health emergency to increase additional capacity for Ben Taub Hospital,” he told commissioners during a meeting on Thursday.
The commissioners raised questions about the level of engagement Harris Health had with the Hermann Park Conservancy Board, which oversees the park’s use. Commissioner Tom Ramsey inquired about the meetings held with the board, to which Dr. Porsa admitted he had only met with the executive director.
The Hermann Park Conservancy (HPC) has begun to voice concerns regarding the proposed land usage. Executive Director Cara Lambright remarked, “For too long, pieces of parkland have been ceded to the Medical Center because it’s the path of least resistance.” Roslyn Bazzelle Mitchell, chair of the HPC board, emphasized the importance of a transparent process, stating, “Before you bring this process to a vote, the public deserves a full and open process.”
Commissioner Adrian Garcia revealed that he only became aware of the eminent domain plans recently, suggesting that the term had not been adequately communicated in prior discussions. “The point of eminent domain came up real late in the conversation,” Garcia noted. In response to the lack of transparency, he introduced a motion requiring Harris Health to conduct four public hearings across the county to discuss the proposed condemnation.
The motion was unanimously approved, mandating that Harris Health provide clear information about the purpose of these meetings. Commissioners expressed hesitation about voting on the condemnation before the holiday season, citing concerns that scheduling a vote on December 11, 2023, would limit public participation. Commissioner Rodney Ellis remarked, “I normally don’t schedule my town hall meetings right before Christmas,” stressing the importance of community input.
Ellis also raised concerns about the financial implications of the plan, suggesting that spending taxpayer money on condemning prime park land may not be the most judicious use of public funds. “Most of the money will go to the family!” he stated, echoing sentiments that the community deserves better consideration regarding the use of parkland.
Long-time civic leader Katheryn McNeil expressed gratitude that all four commissioners are seeking more information before making such a significant decision. This move reflects a growing demand for accountability and transparency in local government actions, particularly regarding public land use.
As discussions continue, Harris County faces a pivotal moment in balancing health care expansion needs with the preservation of public spaces. For ongoing updates, follow Miya Shay on social media platforms.
