UPDATE: Six MLB free agents are set to make a comeback in the 2026 season, according to reports. These players, once stars of the league, are now seeking redemption after challenging seasons characterized by injuries and underperformance.
Fans are always drawn to compelling stories of redemption, and MLB is primed for another wave of “reclamation projects.” Each year, players who have faced adversity manage to turn their fortunes around with new teams. This year, the spotlight falls on six players who are likely to excel in their next chapters, drawing inspiration from previous success stories.
The criteria for these reclamation candidates include being age 27 or older, having previously achieved at least a 2-WAR season, and producing fewer than 2 WAR in the last season. Moreover, these players are expected to change teams, a critical element in their rebounding efforts.
The list of potential comeback stars includes:
1. **Ha-Seong Kim**, SS – Once a 5-WAR player with the San Diego Padres, Kim aims to regain his form after struggling with injuries and team changes.
2. **Michael King**, RHP – After a promising start in 2023 and 2024, King was limited to just 15 starts in 2025 due to injuries, but he is attracting interest from teams looking for a reliable arm.
3. **Luis Arraez**, IF – Known for superb bat-to-ball skills, Arraez will look to replicate the success of Gleyber Torres, who rebounded from a tough stretch with a strong performance in Detroit.
4. **Zac Gallen**, RHP – Declining a qualifying offer from Arizona, Gallen is another candidate for reclamation status after facing a down year compounded by hamstring issues.
5. **Cedric Mullins**, OF – After a tumultuous season with the Orioles and Mets, Mullins is searching for a fresh start, similar to Harrison Bader, who found success after changing teams.
6. **Willi Castro**, OF – Castro previously excelled after leaving Detroit but struggled with the Cubs. His versatility and past performance make him a prime candidate for a comeback.
As these players prepare for the upcoming season, the anticipation builds around whether they can reclaim their success and inspire fans once again. The 2026 season promises to unveil a host of new success stories, as these free agents look to turn the tide and regain their status in the league.
Stay tuned for more updates as the offseason unfolds and these players set their sights on redemption.
