A legal challenge against the closure of the Great Highway in San Francisco has been dismissed by a judge, affirming the city’s decision to convert a section of the highway into a park. On Monday, the court rejected a lawsuit contesting Proposition K, which was approved by voters in 2024 to restrict motor vehicle access to this stretch of road.
The plaintiffs argued that state law prohibits voters from closing a public roadway and claimed the closure contravened the state’s vehicle code and the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Despite these assertions, the ruling reinforces the legal basis for Proposition K.
The advocacy group, Friends of Sunset Dunes, which championed the ballot measure, welcomed the judge’s decision. President Lucas Lux stated, “This ruling affirms Proposition K’s legal foundation,” emphasizing the community support behind the park’s establishment. Lux criticized opposing efforts, stating, “While our volunteers are giving their time to bring a coastal park to life, the anti-park zealots continue to waste more public resources in their attempt to overturn the will of the people and close Sunset Dunes.”
The closure has sparked a divided response, particularly in the Sunset District, where local Supervisor Alan Wong expressed support for a new ballot initiative that would reopen the highway to vehicles on weekdays. Wong stated, “After listening to organizations and individuals across the political spectrum in the Sunset District, it’s clear to me that my values align with a majority of District 4.” He affirmed his readiness to back a measure that would restore the original compromise regarding the highway’s use.
Proposition K received support from nearly 55% of voters citywide, although it has faced opposition in the Sunset District. Former Supervisor Joel Engardio, who had supported the closure and was subsequently recalled by voters in a recent election, commented on the ruling by saying, “It’s time to consider Sunset Dunes settled.” Engardio added, “Future generations will see this as a silly controversy because the park’s benefits far outweigh the fears of traffic jams that never happened. The coast belongs to everyone, and it won’t be long before a majority everywhere will embrace the wonderful and magical Sunset Dunes.”
This ruling is a significant moment for urban park advocates and a reminder of the complexities involved in city planning and community desires. As the Great Highway’s transformation into a park continues, the ongoing dialogue between supporters and critics reflects broader tensions surrounding urban development and public space in San Francisco.
