UPDATE: Plaintiffs in a high-profile lawsuit against the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints are taking urgent action, announcing plans to appeal their case to the U.S. Supreme Court. This development follows the dismissal of their claims by the District of Utah Court and subsequent refusal by the Tenth Circuit Court to hear the case.
The appeal underscores a contentious battle over allegations of tithing misuse and misrepresentation of church history, critical issues that resonate deeply with many church members. The plaintiffs, led by attorney Kay Burningham, aim to challenge a ruling that has left them frustrated and determined to seek justice.
In a statement, Burningham confirmed, “We are committed to pursuing this appeal to ensure that the voices of those who feel misled by the church are heard.” The Supreme Court is known to accept only about 1% of cases, adding urgency to their efforts.
This lawsuit traces back to a class action initiated by Laura Gaddy in 2019. After a series of legal challenges, including a civil racketeer influenced and corrupt organizations (RICO) claim, the case has evolved significantly. Gaddy and other plaintiffs have accused the church of fraudulently misrepresenting how tithing funds are utilized, particularly in relation to the funding of projects like the City Creek Center mall in downtown Salt Lake City.
The court’s dismissal was primarily based on the church’s autonomy and the plaintiffs’ inability to prove a consistent pattern of fraudulent actions. However, the plaintiffs believe their case has merit and are ready to push it to the highest court in the land.
This emerging legal battle is not isolated. It forms part of a broader wave of lawsuits against the church regarding tithing practices. One notable case involved former church member James Huntsman, who sought the return of $5 million in tithes, arguing that funds were misappropriated for non-charitable purposes. Additionally, the church agreed to pay $5 million to the U.S. Treasury in early 2023 for using shell companies to obscure its investment activities.
In November 2023, current and former members filed another lawsuit against the church and its investment arm, Ensign Peak Advisors, claiming their donations were intended solely for charitable purposes. These mounting allegations highlight a growing concern among members regarding the church’s financial transparency.
As the plaintiffs prepare for their Supreme Court appeal, the implications of this case could resonate far beyond the courtroom, affecting the church’s reputation and prompting a reevaluation of its financial practices. Observers are keenly watching how the Supreme Court responds to this significant appeal.
What’s Next: The plaintiffs will file their petition with the Supreme Court in the coming weeks. Legal experts suggest that the outcome could set a precedent for future cases involving religious financial practices.
Stay tuned for more updates as this story develops, and follow us for the latest news on this urgent issue affecting countless individuals and families connected to the church.
