UPDATE: The absence of a nativity scene in Plainville this year has sparked significant controversy, igniting heated discussions among local residents. Traditionally displayed for over 25 years at Veterans Memorial Park, the decision to skip the nativity has left many questioning town officials and their motives.
The Plainville Republicans took to Facebook, accusing the Democratic leadership of the Town Council of essentially canceling the beloved display. They allege that the decision stemmed from a legal opinion requested from town attorney Morris Borea, who indicated that a standalone nativity scene could violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment.
In a detailed analysis dated December 21, 2023, Borea stated that the nativity scene “strongly suggests government endorsement of Christianity.” He explained, “If you have just a nativity scene that’s put up by town personnel on town property, I think there’s a serious legal question there.” His opinion referenced multiple Supreme Court rulings that highlight the need for government neutrality in religious matters.
The Republican posts have generated nearly 500 reactions and around 150 comments, with many expressing their disappointment and advocating for the return of the nativity scene. One post noted the outpouring of support, calling it “refreshing” to see community members rally behind the tradition.
Borea mentioned that discussions about incorporating a Christmas tree at the town library prompted the review of the nativity display. He clarified his personal stance, stating, “I’m Catholic and there’s a nativity scene in front of my church, which I love.” However, he emphasized the importance of adhering to constitutional guidelines in government practices.
The town now faces two options, as outlined by Borea: either incorporate the nativity scene into a larger, secular holiday display, or establish a “public forum” policy allowing community groups to place holiday displays. This approach would ensure equal treatment of all holiday representations on town property.
Republicans argue that a potential solution could have included adding secular decorations to the nativity scene, rather than omitting it entirely. They are hopeful that the Town Council will convene to discuss policy changes in the near future.
As the debate continues, residents of Plainville are left wondering what will happen next. Will a compromise be reached in time for the holiday season? The town council’s forthcoming meetings may provide clarity on this contentious issue.
Officials did not respond to requests for immediate comments, leaving the community awaiting answers. The implications of this decision resonate deeply, not just for Plainville but also for towns across the country grappling with similar challenges concerning religious displays.
Stay tuned for further updates as this story develops.
